Дисертації з теми "Airflow in street canyons"
Оформте джерело за APA, MLA, Chicago, Harvard та іншими стилями
Ознайомтеся з топ-34 дисертацій для дослідження на тему "Airflow in street canyons".
Біля кожної праці в переліку літератури доступна кнопка «Додати до бібліографії». Скористайтеся нею – і ми автоматично оформимо бібліографічне посилання на обрану працю в потрібному вам стилі цитування: APA, MLA, «Гарвард», «Чикаго», «Ванкувер» тощо.
Також ви можете завантажити повний текст наукової публікації у форматі «.pdf» та прочитати онлайн анотацію до роботи, якщо відповідні параметри наявні в метаданих.
Переглядайте дисертації для різних дисциплін та оформлюйте правильно вашу бібліографію.
Glover, N. "Investigating the impact of trees on airflow within street canyons through the use of CFD and field measurements." Thesis, University College London (University of London), 2015. http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/1472912/.
Повний текст джерелаMaison, Alice. "Modélisation des impacts des arbres sur la qualité de l’air de l’échelle de la rue à la ville." Electronic Thesis or Diss., Marne-la-vallée, ENPC, 2023. http://www.theses.fr/2023ENPC0034.
Повний текст джерелаTrees provide numerous ecosystem services in cities, helping to reduce some of the consequences of urbanization, such as the urban heat island and water run-off. Their thermo-radiative effect improves thermal comfort.Trees can also have an impact on urban air quality through various processes. The deposition of gaseous and particulate pollutants on tree leaves can help to reduce concentrations. However, the aerodynamic effect of trees modifies the airflow in street canyons and limits the dispersion of pollutants emitted in the street. Trees also emit biogenic volatile organic compounds (BVOCs), which can contribute to the formation of O3 and secondary organic aerosols. BVOC emissions vary depending on the tree species, and are influenced by climatic factors (temperature, radiation) and by the tree water status.The objective of this thesis is to quantify the impacts of these different processes on urban air quality. Numerical simulations are performed over the city of Paris during summer 2022 using the CHIMERE/MUNICH model chain in order to quantify the impact of trees on atmospheric concentrations of pollutants at the local and regional scales. The simulated concentrations are compared to measurements.Urban trees are not generally taken into account in air quality models, either at regional or street level. In order to integrate BVOC emissions into the CHIMERE regional model, an inventory is developed using the tree database of the city of Paris. A method is set up to estimate the characteristics of the trees, which are used as input data for the various models (leaf area, dry biomass, crown size, etc.). On average over the months of June and July 2022 in Paris, local biogenic emissions from trees lead to an increase of 1.0% in O3, 4.6% in organic PM1 and 0.6% in PM2.5. Biogenic emissions from urban trees strongly increase concentrations of isoprene and monoterpenes. Compared with measurements, terpene concentrations tend to be underestimated, given the uncertainties associated with emission factors and the missing part of the vegetation in the inventory. Terpene emissions from urban and suburban vegetation greatly influence the formation of organic particles, it is therefore important to characterize them properly in air quality models.The various effects of urban trees on air quality at street level are then added into the MUNICH street network model. The aerodynamic effect of street trees is parameterized using computational fluid dynamics simulations. It leads to an increase in the concentrations of compounds emitted into the street. This increase can reach +37% for NO2 in streets with a large leaf surface and high traffic. Deposition on tree leaves is computed using a resistive approach adapted to the scale of the tree in the street. However, its impact on concentrations remains limited for the gases and particles studied (< -3%).Finally, a coupling between the TEB (urban surface model), SPAC (soil-plant-atmosphere continuum model) and MUNICH models is developed. This coupling provides a better representation of the impacts of the urban micro-climate heterogeneities and of the thermo-radiative effect of trees on gas and particle concentrations. The effects of the micro-climate and of the tree water stress on BVOC emissions are also taken into account in order to refine the calculation of emissions
Huang, Pong-Lai. "Modelling of air quality in street canyons /." View Abstract or Full-Text, 2003. http://library.ust.hk/cgi/db/thesis.pl?AMCE%202003%20HUANG.
Повний текст джерелаYunkai, Yang. "Numerical study on flow and pollutant dispersion inside street canyons." Licentiate thesis, KTH, Installationsteknik, 2013. http://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:kth:diva-118327.
Повний текст джерелаQC 20130215
Stachitas, Tucker Flagg. "Evaluation of 3-D radiant heat transfer in street canyons." [Gainesville, Fla.] : University of Florida, 2009. http://purl.fcla.edu/fcla/etd/UFE0041302.
Повний текст джерелаWong, Ching-chi, and 黃精治. "Flow and pollutant dispersion over idealized urban street canyons using large-eddy simulation." Thesis, The University of Hong Kong (Pokfulam, Hong Kong), 2013. http://hdl.handle.net/10722/206698.
Повний текст джерелаpublished_or_final_version
Mechanical Engineering
Doctoral
Doctor of Philosophy
Hall, Terianne C. "Predicting velocities and turbulent exchange in isolated street canyons and at a neighborhood scale." Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2010. http://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/61867.
Повний текст джерелаCataloged from PDF version of thesis.
Includes bibliographical references (p. 127-130).
Urban planners need a fast, simple model to assess the impact of early design phase iterations of neighborhood layout on the microclimate. Specifically, this model should be able to predict the expected urban heat island intensity and the locations in neighborhood layouts that are prone to pollutant retention. Current models are inadequate for this purpose because they use computationally intensive techniques to solve for flow through a neighborhood and often require a strong technical background for effective use of the models. In this thesis, we use analytical equations and empirical relationships to calculate the expected wind speeds in isolated, idealized street canyons. We demonstrate that flow in street canyons is driven by momentum exchange with the air above. We discuss the importance of flow separation and turbulent exchange between the urban canopy layer and the urban boundary layer for removing heat and pollutants from street canyons. Next, we introduce a method to parameterize this exchange and extend this work to more realistic street canyons and idealized neighborhoods. We evaluate this work using computational fluid dynamics and comparison to experimental results and models from the literature. We examine cases where the flow is influenced by buoyancy effects and assess the applicability of our work in these situations. Finally, we address how this work could be further developed into generalized planning guidelines and incorporated into a comprehensive model for urban planners.
by Terianne Catherine Hall.
S.M.
Barbano, Francesco <1991>. "Characterization of turbulent exchange processes in real urban street canyons with and without vegetation." Doctoral thesis, Alma Mater Studiorum - Università di Bologna, 2020. http://amsdottorato.unibo.it/9452/1/barbano_francesco_tesi.pdf.
Повний текст джерелаRusticali, Valeria. "Confronto tra distribuzioni dimensionali di particelle misurate in due street canyons della città di Bologna." Bachelor's thesis, Alma Mater Studiorum - Università di Bologna, 2018. http://amslaurea.unibo.it/16780/.
Повний текст джерелаPolito, Martina. "Mean flow and turbulent exchange characteristics in real urban street canyons: the Lazzaretto case study." Master's thesis, Alma Mater Studiorum - Università di Bologna, 2019.
Знайти повний текст джерелаLeung, Ka-kit Pieta, and 梁家杰. "On the study of ventilation and pollutant removal over idealized two-dimensional urban street canyons." Thesis, The University of Hong Kong (Pokfulam, Hong Kong), 2012. http://hub.hku.hk/bib/B48521863.
Повний текст джерелаpublished_or_final_version
Mechanical Engineering
Master
Master of Philosophy
Hassan, Abdel Galiel A. "Computer modelling of the dispersion of air pollutants associated with vehicle emissions in street canyons." Thesis, Glasgow Caledonian University, 1996. http://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.688238.
Повний текст джерелаChung, Nga-hang, and 鍾雅行. "Large-eddy simulation of transport of inert and chemically reactive pollutants over 2D idealized street canyons." Thesis, The University of Hong Kong (Pokfulam, Hong Kong), 2011. http://hub.hku.hk/bib/B47849903.
Повний текст джерелаpublished_or_final_version
Mechanical Engineering
Master
Master of Philosophy
Mumovic, Dejan. "3-D numerical modelling of dispersion of air pollutants in a complex configuration of street canyons." Thesis, Glasgow Caledonian University, 2004. http://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.404618.
Повний текст джерелаSmith, James O. "Determination of the convective heat transfer coefficients from the surfaces of buildings within urban street canyons." Thesis, University of Bath, 2010. https://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.518100.
Повний текст джерелаCheng, Wai-chi, and 鄭偉智. "Wind and pollutant removal of urban street canyons under different thermal stratification by RANS and LES models." Thesis, The University of Hong Kong (Pokfulam, Hong Kong), 2010. http://hub.hku.hk/bib/B46289653.
Повний текст джерелаLongley, Ian. "High resolution measurements of turbulent transport of particulate matter in the urban street canyons in Manchester, UK." Thesis, University of Manchester, 2003. http://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.607148.
Повний текст джерелаLi, Xianxiang, and 李顯祥. "Large-eddy simulation of wind flow and air pollutant transport inside urban street canyons of different aspect ratios." Thesis, The University of Hong Kong (Pokfulam, Hong Kong), 2008. http://hub.hku.hk/bib/B40687326.
Повний текст джерелаLi, Xianxiang. "Large-eddy simulation of wind flow and air pollutant transport inside urban street canyons of different aspect ratios." Click to view the E-thesis via HKUTO, 2008. http://sunzi.lib.hku.hk/hkuto/record/B40687326.
Повний текст джерелаCarrasco, Hernandez Roberto. "Calculation of patterns of solar radiation within urban geometries." Thesis, University of Manchester, 2015. https://www.research.manchester.ac.uk/portal/en/theses/calculation-of-patterns-of-solar-radiation-within-urban-geometries(5ac30e2c-0713-4217-8680-a2035d982710).html.
Повний текст джерелаBoddy, John William Douglas. "The influence of meteorology, urban topography and traffic on the variability in concentrations of a traffic-related pollutant in urban street canyons." Thesis, University of Leeds, 2005. http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/173/.
Повний текст джерелаOlofsson, Linus. "Mass conservative network model for convective net flow in a complex urban geometry." Thesis, Umeå universitet, Institutionen för fysik, 2016. http://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:umu:diva-123270.
Повний текст джерелаChung, Sen-Jyh, and 莊森智. "Air Pollution Transport In Street Canyons." Thesis, 1995. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/98648461423225392414.
Повний текст джерела淡江大學
水資源及環境工程所
83
The transport of air pollutants in a street canyon is simul- ated for different atmospherical stabilities, traffic conditions and street caynon geometry. The simulation domain includes the atmospheric boundary layer which cover both sub- urban and urban areas. The simulation tool is a finite element method based CFD package:FIDAP. The results of the numerical calculations shows that a sing- le vortex is maintained within a canyons.A second vortex appears when aspect ratio is greater than certain critical value under various meteorological conditions. This phenomenon then results in local high concentration on leeward、 windward side or near ground within a canyon rather than that of the one vortex case. In addition, the pollutant concentration will increases as the aspect ratio increases, and decreases exponentially in the vertical direction.
Lai, Chien-Chang, and 賴建璋. "Simulation of Turbulent Flow in Zigzag street canyons." Thesis, 1998. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/27617678830411662506.
Повний текст джерела淡江大學
水資源及環境工程學系
86
This research uses Finite Analytic Method to simulate "Street Canyons" formed by city buildings and streets in atmospheric boundary layer. Because Street Canyons are complex structures on the Earth's surface, they may produce different kinds of nonuniform flow field.This thesis first compares the flow field variations in both laminar flow and turbulent flow under different height-width ratios. The laminar flow fields were solved from Navie-Stokes motion equation and continuity equation. For turbulent flow we used k-ε-E(ddy) turbulent model to simulate the turbulent flow field.The height-width ratios of "Street Canyons" are divided into three categories. The first category of the Street Canyon is low on the left and high on the right. The height-width ratios of it are 0.75, 1.0, 1.25, 1.5 and 1.75. The second category of the Street Canyons has equal heights. The height-width ratios of it are 0.5,1.0,1.5 and 2.0. The third category is one which is higher on the left hand side and lower in the right hand side. And the height-width ratios are 0.75, 1.0, 1.25, 1.5, 1.75. Then, we compare the size, location, and numbers of vortexes when laminar flow and turbulent flow are of the same height-width ratios. Finally, we compare the differences between turbulent flow using Wall- Function and turbulent flow not using Wall-Function The Results Of Simulation Are: Laminar flow:Only one vortex is produced in the first category of Street Canyons. The center of vortex in the second category increases with the rising of height-width ratios and the second vortex shows up in this category, too. When the second vortex appears in the third category and the difference between the heights of two structures is high, the center of the first vortex will move to down stream.Turbulent flow: There are two vortexes in the first category. When the second vortex shows up in the second category and the height- width ratio is 1.0, the center of vortex is about half high of the structure. When the second vortex appears in the third category and the difference of heights between two structures is high, the first vortex center will move to down stream. Differences between laminar and turbulent flows: The second vortex of turbulent flow always shows up earlier than that of laminar flow. The vortex center of turbulent flow is lower than that of laminar flow when the height-width ratio is 1.0. Thus, we can know the momentum transmission ability of turbulent flow is stronger than that of laminar flow. Wall-Function: The main structure is basically the same except there are some differences in the boundary, when comparing the circumstances between using and not using the Wall-Function.
Lai, Jian-Zhang, and 賴建璋. "Simulation of Turbulent Flow in Zigzag street canyons." Thesis, 1998. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/03778315047889668392.
Повний текст джерелаLu, Cheng-Chung, and 呂政忠. "Buoyant Effect to The Pollutants Transport in Street Canyons." Thesis, 1996. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/29043348645998535450.
Повний текст джерела淡江大學
水資源及環境工程學系
84
Carbon monoxide distribution in street canyons under various geometry''s,atmospheric stability, temperature gradient induced buoyant effect and trafficload were simulated. We intend to use the simulation results to evaluatepedestrian pollutant exposure and to provide external conditions forevaluating indoor air quality of the buildings beside urban street. In thisstudy, we consider several factors those may affect the pollutant distributionin street canyons. The considered factors include geometry of the streetcanyons, atmospheric stability, traffic load and turbulent buoyant effect. Atwo-dimensional domain that includes suburban roughness and urban streetcanyons was considered as the simulation domain. The considered influentialfactors were imposed into the simulation through the associated boundaryconditions. The simulated results show that serious pollutant accumulationoccurred at where double vortices encountered and the situation only occurredat specific aspect ratios of the street canyons. Usually, the stagnation zoneformed at where the encounter of two vortices that reduce the transport ofpollutant and the pollutant tent to accumulate at the region. Buoyant effectto the vortices formation was found that the double vortices occurred atsmaller aspect ratio of the canyons with buoyancy than those without buoyancy. The buoyant effect also change the pollutant transport pattern in the canyons.The pedestrian exposure to the street air pollutant under various trafficloads and atmospheric stability were evaluated. This study concluded that thepatterns of pollutant distribution in different street canyons are mostlyaffected by their aspect ratios where the affect of buoyancy and atmosphericstability played less role. The pedestrian exposure to the street airpollution is considered to be serious under specific conditions when pollutantconcentrations at 3 m above ground level are very high. Those specificconditions were also found in this study.
Lin, Chin-Hsien, and 林金賢. "Model of Air Pollutants transportion in street canyons with different height arrangement." Thesis, 2004. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/02799651922614512627.
Повний текст джерела淡江大學
水資源及環境工程學系
92
Air pollution in big city areas resulting from exhaust emissions is a major urban problem. Often traffic pollution excess controls air pollution management decisions. The pollutants emitted from motor vehicles have direct impact on human health, especially on the drivers, bicyclists, motorcyclists, pedestrians, people working nearby and vehicle passengers in urban street canyon with high-rise buildings in most large cities. This study presents ventilation behavior in different height of street canyon configurations. To evaluate dispersion in a model urban street canyon, a series of tests with various street canyon aspect ratios (B/H) in upwind and downwind of street canyon are presented. Physical modeling in wind tunnels and numerical modeling can be used for dispersion simulation when investing air quality. The flow and dispersion of gases emitted by line source located between two buildings. A two-dimension numerical model based on Reyonlds-averaged Navier-Stokes equations coupled with a serious of standard, Renormalization Group(RNG) and realizable κ-εturbulence models was developed to simulate the fluid-flow development and pollutant dispersion within different height street canyon using the FLUENT code.Calculations are compared against fluid modeling in an Environmental Wind Tunnel of Wind Engineering Center at Tamkang University. These buildings were arranged in various symmetric configurations with different height ratios in upwind and downwind of street canyon. The fluid-flow development has demonstrated that the vortices generated within the urban street canyon can transport the pollutants form a line source to wall surfaces of the building. Different height arrangement of street canyons were found that pollutant concentration in leeward side is not bigger than windward side . The Pollutant concentration in wind tunnel test and simulation by FLUENT code had corresponding resluts.
PO-CHUN, WANG, and 王柏鈞. "Studying the Influence of the Arcade Space on the Microclimateof Urban Street Canyons." Thesis, 2016. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/4zu5eg.
Повний текст джерела國立臺北科技大學
能源與冷凍空調工程系碩士班
104
Arcade is a partly open comfortable space for people to take shelter from the wind, rain and sunlight in a highly urbanized environment. Accompanying with the urban renewal incentives proposed by domestic country and municipal governments, those buildings having arcade spaces were increasingly replaced by the design concept of "setback of architectures", leading to gradual disappearance of unique Taiwan street culture. Above all, there are no studies conducted to probe the influences of arcade buildings on the microclimates. This research aims to conduct the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations and field measurements for resolving the microclimate environments around the subject building complex with arcade spaces in highly urbanized areas. It is expected to implement the results obtained to the urban design guidelines for improving the pedestrian comfort level and microclimate state.
Awasthi, Seema. "Physical modeling and numerical simulation study of line source dispersion in urban street canyons." Thesis, 2006. http://localhost:8080/xmlui/handle/12345678/2987.
Повний текст джерелаLee, Ying-Chen, and 李映辰. "A Numerical Study of the Temperature Reduction by Water Spray Systems within Urban Street Canyons." Thesis, 2017. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/8j96zk.
Повний текст джерела國立臺灣大學
生物環境系統工程學研究所
105
Urban heat islands rapidly increase energy demand for air conditioning. To reduce the energy demand for cooling the environment, some possible solutions have been studied and applied. Among these methods, the water spray system is considered most effective and flexible with its dynamic controls. To simulate the cooling effect of water spray system, numerical simulation with Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) is used. This simulation was validated with water channel and wind tunnel experiments. The goal of this study is to simulate the cooling effect in the street canyon with different aspect ratio in high relative humidity (70% and 80%) environment, which is often the case in Taipei city. The results showed that if relative humidity is larger than 70%, the air cooled by small water droplets was easily saturated. Large water droplets almost saturated the air just under the nozzles. If the nozzle height was increased from 2.5 m to 3.5 m, the air under the nozzles was completely saturated, and reached wet bulb temperature, which is the lowest bound of temperature. The coolest region is just below the nozzles because the wind in street canyon is too weak to blow the cold air away. However, in a narrow street, people may feel the cooling effect in the middle of the street because the accumulation of the cold air.
Chen, Yu-Shan, and 陳佑姍. "Wind Tunnel Study on the Dispersion Characteristics of Elevated Point Source Discharging in Different Street Canyons." Thesis, 2013. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/24236547465568802284.
Повний текст джерелаChen, Yi-Pin, and 陳奕賓. "Studying the Influences of Arcade Space on Improvement of Microclimate and Mitigation of Air Pollution in Urban Street Canyons." Thesis, 2017. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/nhr44b.
Повний текст джерела國立臺北科技大學
能源與冷凍空調工程系碩士班
106
The development of high-density urban street canyons toward dense high-rise buildings causes the decline of ventilation rate and pollutant accumulation resulting from the breezeless state in the downtown area. Lately, the corridor concept has been extensively proposed during the layout, design and construction processes of city buildings. Corridors are arranged to align with the prevailing wind for bringing the wind into cities, and therefore to disperse the outdoor air pollution and promote the indoor air circulation. This study implements the environmental CFD based analysis procedures to construct a three-dimensional computational model for replicating the high-density urban buildings with corridors. By varying the effects of configurations of corridor, shape of buildings, and the distance between two neighboring streets, the iii fluid fields and air pollution dispersal were thoroughly investigated to evaluate the microclimate environments around the subject building with corridors. Besides, field measurements were conducted to provide the database for model validation. We then apply the verified CFD tool to predict the detailed airflow characteristics of urban environment as well as perform multivariable regression analysis for determining the correlation of the corridor design parameters with the air exchange rate per hour (ACH) for ventilation and the lessening of pollutant levels in environs.
林信漢. "Wind Tunnel Study on the Dipersion Characteristics of the Airborne Pollution on the Triangles Terrain with Different Slope Angles and Street Canyons." Thesis, 2013. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/52266670203516883676.
Повний текст джерела國立臺灣海洋大學
河海工程學系
101
In the present thesis, wind tunnel experiments were conducted to study the dispersion characteristics of the airborne pollution on the triangle terrain with different slope angles and various distances between the terrain and street canyons. In the experiments, the airborne pollution source was located at the toe of the downwind slope of terrain. The triangle terrain with equal upwind and downwind slope which were 15∘and 30∘. Building heights in the street were the same with terrain model height. The height denoted by H. The vortex generators and roughness elements were appropriately arranged in the test section of wind tunnel to simulate the neutral atmospheric boundary layer flows which used as the approaching flow for the experiments. The distance between the triangle terrain and front row building of street canyon were 2H and 4H. Effects of the downwind slope angle of terrain and the distance between the triangle terrain and front row building of street canyon on the pollution dispersion characteristics (such as pollution plume averaged height and dispersion parameters) were investigated in this study.
徐秉鴻. "Studying the Influences of Pedestrian Bridge Design on Outdoor and Indoor Microclimate Environments over Street Canyons and Passage Space in a Dense High-Rise Buildings." Thesis, 2019. http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/g92e8k.
Повний текст джерела國立臺北科技大學
能源與冷凍空調工程系
107
Pedestrian bridges are designed to separate pedestrians from vehicles on the road to improve traffic and pedestrian safety. However, the presence of pedestrian bridges may deteriorate the microclimates in street canyons. The development of high-density urban street canyons toward dense high-rise buildings causes the decline of ventilation rate, heat island effect and pollutant accumulation resulting from the breezeless state in the downtown area. Based on the local microclimate and urban conditions, this study applies the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation technology to explore the influences of pedestrian bridge design between buildings on the air ventilation, thermal comfort and pollution dispersion of the indoor and outdoor spaces of the bridge and street canyons. The results show that the impact of pedestrian bridge structures on the local microclimate environment is insignificant for low and medium-rise buildings. Change the width (3m, 6m, 9m), interior height (3m, 4m, no cap) and barrier’s height (1.25m, 2m, 2.75m) of pedestrian bridge to analyze the velocity, temperature and pollution distributed over the internal passage space of pedestrian bridge. In addition, this paper explores the air ventilation, thermal comfort results and pollution removal rate in terms of the air exchange rate per hour (ACH), physiological equivalent temperature (PET) and purging flow rate (PFR) performance to maximize the comfort of pedestrians. The results show that the reduction of bridge’s width reduces the path of airflow, and flow resistance is lower, the velocity is relatively higher. Therefore, the bridge with narrow width (Case1 of pedestrian bridge’s width is 3m) shows the best ACH result, but the bridge’s width variation has no obvious influences on the temperature inside the bridge with effect of solar radiation and convection of heat transfer. No top cap (Case5) and higher barrier’s height (Case7 of barrier’s height is 2.75m) cause PET thermal sensitivity to be hot (38°C~42°C), except for them, the other Case’s PET results are warm (34°C~38 °C). Change the configuration of the pedestrian bridge on blocking the pollution is not significant, the wider pedestrian bridge (Case3 of pedestrian bridge’s width is 9m) has the best PFR value.