CESCATO, SILVIA. "Bambini, genitori, educatori al nido d'infanzia. Un'esplorazione "micropedagogica" dei momenti di transizione." Doctoral thesis, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, 2012. http://hdl.handle.net/10281/37950.
Abstract:
SUMMARY
This work is part of research on early childhood education and it takes up and develops studies
that have investigated the relationships between adults (parents and educators) and between
children and adults in ECEC settings in particular. The aim was to investigate the interactive
dynamics that develop between parents, educators and children during transitions from the
family to the school context (morning arrival and early afternoon leaving), linking microanalytical
interaction analysis with the exploration of interpretation processes by the educators
involved. The assumption is that moments of "ecological transition" (Bronfenbrenner, 1979),
when parents and educators share and negotiate the transfer of educational responsibilities
regarding the child, are atypical moments in the daily routines at school, creating the opportunity
for focusing on the interactions between parents and educators in the presence of children, thus
creating privileged educational opportunities that make the ideas and meanings attributed to these
interactions by the protagonists themselves emerge in a more "natural" way.
Numerous studies have focused on teaching the specificity of these transition events (Barbieri et
al., 1983, Angelini et al., 1983, Maltempi, 1986, Comotti, Varin, 1988, Varin, Crugnola Riva, 1996)
and their central role in building good relationships between services and families (Milani, 2009),
drawing attention to the role of observing interaction in teacher training. Research in the ECEC,
in particular, has highlighted the need to support educators so that they are builders of rituals and
routines which support the separation between parent and child, consistent with the relationship
style (Mantovani, Saitta, Bove, 2000, Carli, 2002). However, in theory, almost all studies that have
investigated this dimension refer to dyadic relational types (i.e. focused on the parent-child or
teacher-child pair), often based on studies which refer to attachment theory (Bowlby, 1973,
Ainsworth et al.,1978) and rarely have they included observing behavior to reveal the subjective
ideas of the adults involved.
The challenge is to go back and study these moments, guided by the theoretical and
methodological indications that emerge from the most recent psychological research on how to
analyze the micro-processes involved in interaction dynamics in educational settings, adopting a
triadic, process-oriented perspective (Fivaz-Depeursinge, Corboz-Warnery, 1999, Tremblay-
Leveau, 1999; Simonelli et al., 2012). The authors suggest reinterpreting micro-analytic
observation in a pedagogical perspective, since it can help expand educational research regarding
these issues in a situated, rigorous yet relevant way for training the teachers involved.
Through observing interactions in a triadic perspective, this thesis considers the educationally
relevant possibility of focusing not so much, or not only, on the (temporary) separation of the
parent-child pair. The micro-processes of transition and confidence in the teacher-parent-child
triad, their mutual positions, alliances, or dis-alliances are considered educational. Attention is
also placed on the factors that make transition dynamics more or less smooth. At the same time,
the study adopts a phenomenological, micro-pedagogical perspective (Bertolini, 1997, Mortari,
2007, Caronia, 2011) (Demetrio, 1992) and describes the interactive dynamics in light of the
micro-analytical meanings assigned to them by the protagonists (Stern, 1995, 2004) in an attempt
to put the observed behavior in relation to the more "hidden" ideas and educational models.
From a methodological point of view, the study follows the field research tradition in education
(Lumbelli, 1980, Mantovani, 1998) and combines qualitative research tools (focus groups,
interviews, observations) with some recent methodological innovations, developed in the field of
video research, using video in educational contexts (Goldman et al., 2007, Bove, 2008, 2009). In
this sense, the study can be understood as a "pilot study on the method", since it explores the
"training latencies" (Bove, 2009) of the tools and methods used, examining the importance of
pedagogical training microanalysis and video, and in particular the microanalysis of interaction.
These tools seem to offer interesting implications for extended reflection and research in
educational services. Perhaps they can focus attention on micro-interactive processes, thereby
bringing out the ideas of educators, facilitating the detailed study of reflexivity process practices
which can link knowing-observing with the cognitive-interpretive-reflective sphere.
This idiographic study was conducted at an ECEC in Parma with the following objectives: to
observe, describe and analyze the interactive and relational dynamics patterns that developed
between adults (parents, teachers) and children during transition to school from a microanalytical
perspective; to gather the ideas of educators on some specific transition episodes,
stimulating microanalytical reconstruction processes; to explore the educational potential of a
mixed methodological approach (visual and narrative) based on behavior observation
descriptions and reflection regarding the meanings ascribed to them by educators, who were the
protagonists. In general, we aimed at pedagogically focusing on moments of "home-school
transition" to help reduce the distance that often separates the discourses of educators regarding
the relationship with the family from the daily practices put into effect in contexts, re-centering
the attention of educators on their roles and their responsibilities and to observe the interactive
competence of children and parents.
Empirically, the research was divided into three phases, each involving the teachers in the ECEC,
which was the research context, during different moments of observation and reflection on their
individual and intersubjective behaviors. In the first stage, we explored the ideas and conceptions
of the teachers about education by conducting informal interviews, group discussions and
participant observations. During the second phase, we explored the teachers' ideas regarding
interaction with children and parents in greater depth through microanalytic interviews - echoing
the method originally developed by Stern (1995) - aimed at fostering the narration of transition
episodes deemed more or less "positive" by the teachers themselves. At the same time, were
observed and videotaped 100 episodes of the "input and output" of the children and their
parents, 40 hours of which were subsequently selected as a representative sample for the microanalysis
of the interactions observed, in an effort to identify patterns or recurring patterns of
interaction. Finally, during the third phase of research, the teachers involved in the video
recordings were invited to participate in an exercise in order to reconstruct their critical-reflexive
behaviors mediated by images, to make them more aware by observing and analyzing the
dynamic interaction processes and reflecting on their behavior and their assumptions.
The data analysis (visual and narrative) made it possible to highlight the following aspects:
- First, the microanalysis of the observed situations focused on the complexity of these transition
moments, highlighting the role of teachers and the often non-verbal interactive skills of very
young children;
- Analysis of discourses, and therefore the meanings, collected during the interviews and the
subsequent discussion with the teachers about the videos showed the changes in how the
protagonist-teachers commented on and interpreted their roles in welcoming the children to
school, including their reconsideration of the competences of children and parents.
Overall, the results of this study allow us to confirm the educational value of the videomicroanalysis
of interactions, which could also be further developed with respect to its impact on
the behavior of educators.