Posselt, Amanda J. "Are Nutrients the Key Driver in Prompting Dominance of Toxic Cyanobacterial Blooms in a Sub-Tropical Reservoir?" Thesis, Griffith University, 2010. http://hdl.handle.net/10072/367306.
Abstract:
Toxic cyanobacteria cause major problems, both for drinking and recreation, within
water systems and bulk water storages, worldwide. Many investigations have been
conducted to determine how, and why, they proliferate as well as why, and when, they
produce toxins. A common assumption is that cyanobacteria grow in response to an
increase in water column nutrient availability, but this is an oversimplification.
In a sub-tropical reservoir (L. Samsonvale, South East Queensland, Australia), the
toxic cyanobacterium Cylindrospermopsis raciborskii has been dominating the
phytoplankton community in the summer months for many years. The reason for this
is unknown. Lake Samsonvale typically has relatively low phosphorus (P)
concentrations, relatively high nitrogen (N) concentrations and C. raciborskii can
grow without significant nutrient inputs from the catchment or point sources. The
relatively high N concentrations in L. Samsonvale mean that it is unlikely to be a key
nutrient in promoting dominance of C. raciborskii. The low phosphorus (in particular
the phosphate) concentrations on the other hand may suggest a reason for
C. raciborskii dominance in L. Samsonvale. Studies of a non-toxic strain of
C. raciborskii originally isolated from the northern hemisphere found that a rapid
phosphate uptake rate and high phosphorus storage capacity was contributing to its
dominance in a phosphate-limited reservoir (Istvánovics et al. 2000).
The aim of this thesis was to characterise the relationship between phosphorus and
C. raciborskii in L. Samsonvale. To achieve this, three levels of investigation were
used: 1. Physiological studies at the species level; 2. Manipulative experiments at the
phytoplankton community level; 3. Characterisation of C. raciborskii ecology at the
whole of system level.
The relationship between C. raciborskii and phosphorus was studied using a
multilevel approach. Knowledge gained from this allowed detailed investigation of
iii
the relationship between the dominance of this species within the phytoplankton
community of L. Samsonvale.
Using continuous culture experiments, the phosphate uptake and storage capacity of
two toxic Australian strains of C. raciborskii was determined. One of these strains
was isolated from the reservoir of interest, L. Samsonvale. P dependent growth rate
and toxin production were also quantified. Both strains of C. raciborskii had a high
maximum phosphate uptake rate (450 – 600 μmol P mg C-1 d-1) with a relative low
half saturation constant (0.64 μmol P L-1). This study suggests that C. raciborskii is
capable of taking full advantage of any available phosphate that may be introduced
(such as run off) or regenerated within the phytoplankton/bacterial community. The P
dependent growth rates were similar for both strains of C. raciborskii with a
maximum growth rate at the lowest concentration of P tested (0.03 μmol P L-1).
Growth rates were lower overall than in other strains of C. raciborskii. When
C. raciborskii cells were starved of P, they produced much more toxin than when they
were grown in a nutrient sufficient environment. This indicates that toxin production
may be related to a stress response.
Some phytoplankton have been shown to produce alkaline phosphatase. This enzyme
cleaves phosphate from organically bound forms, targeting esters, which can be taken
up and used by the cell. Since C. raciborskii appears to proliferate in phosphate
limited systems, its potential to secrete this enzyme, and whether it was capable of
growth with an organically bound source of phosphate, were investigated. Alkaline
phosphatase activity was detected and C. raciborskii was found to be capable of
multiplying in a culture media containing only an organic form of P (glucose-6-
phosphate, G-6-P). However, the maximum growth rate was lower (~0.13 d-1) when
cells were grown in G-6-P compared to phosphate (~0.22 d-1) The ability of
C. raciborskii to use: 1. Organic P; 2. Rapidly utilise phosphate; and 3. Grow at a
maximum rate at relatively low phosphate concentrations, are likely to make
C. raciborskii a dominant competitor in phosphate-limited systems.
iv
To determine whether C. raciborskii has a competitive advantage over other
phytoplankton in the P-limited system of L. Samsonvale, in situ dialysis tube
bioassays were used to test the phytoplankton response to nutrient addition. The
dialysis tube bioassay is a novel approach aiming to minimise the confounding
problem of artificial nutrient limitation associated with traditional closed bottle
bioassays. Samples of the phytoplankton population were subjected to nutrient
additions at four different times over a summer period, to test whether a change in
phytoplankton species composition (with particular reference to C. raciborskii) could
be seen after four days. In phytoplankton communities where the proportion of
C. raciborskii was equal to, or above, 50% (biovolume), a statistically significant
increase in C. raciborskii dominance occurred when phosphate was added as a daily
spike at either of two concentrations (0.32 and 16 μM P). However, C. raciborskii
dominance decreased when phosphate was constantly added in very high
concentrations or when N and P are added together. From the bioassay experiments it
can be inferred that C. raciborskii has a competitive advantage in L. Samsonvale due
to its ability to rapidly take up phosphate. But, when the phosphate concentration is
constantly high (>6.4 μmol P L-1), C. raciborskii loses this competitive advantage.
Analysis of historical data has shown that there is no correlation between periodic
nutrient inputs (e.g. rainfall) and an increase in C. raciborskii dominance. The
mechanisms by which C. raciborskii is accessing phosphate within L. Samsonvale
were therefore examined.
One theory about how C. raciborskii is accessing phosphate in L. Samsonvale is that
it comes from nutrient injections in the bottom waters caused by mixing the reservoir
using artificial destratification. The concentration of dissolved organic phosphorus
(DOP) may also provide C. raciborskii with available phosphate. To assess these two
hypotheses, the nutrient concentration and phytoplankton cell concentrations
throughout the water column were measured, both before and after artificial
destratification. The DOP fraction was measured over a summer. Phosphate remained
v
below detection limits throughout the study, therefore the role of the destratifier in
injecting phosphate into the water column was difficult to determine. A difference in
phytoplankton distribution was noted with C. raciborskii being found at higher
concentrations lower in the water column post destratification. In contrast, the other
toxic species of cyanobacteria Microcystis aeruginosa present in substantial cell
concentrations significantly decreased in cell concentrations after the destratifier was
turned on. DOP was found to be a significant fraction (total mean 32%) of the total P
in the water column of L. Samsonvale and may therefore provide an important source
of P for C. raciborskii under low phosphate conditions.
This study has shown C. raciborskii has adapted to the low concentrations of P in
L. Samsonvale to gain a competitive advantage. Reservoir management, particularly
in relation to nutrient loads, should take this into account, as efforts to reduce P loads
may not lead to a decrease in C. raciborskii cell number or phytoplankton dominance.
Thesis (PhD Doctorate)
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
Griffith School of Environment
Science, Environment, Engineering and Technology
Full Text